The pain of saying goodbye is undeniable, often leading to drawn-out farewells. Such was the case with Google’s planned phase-out of third-party cookies, the cornerstone of cross-site tracking and targeted advertising. After initially promising to eliminate third-party, or “tracking,” cookies “within two years” back in January 2020, Google repeatedly pushed back the deadline.
We say it “was” the case because Google has just changed its mind. Instead of bidding farewell to third-party cookies for good, the company now plans to hold on to them, potentially indefinitely.
In a blog post titled inconspicuously “A New Path for Privacy Sandbox on the Web,” Google’s VP Anthony Chavez quietly dropped a bombshell: he announced that while Google remains committed to implementing the Privacy Sandbox APIs—initially pitched as a more private alternative to third-party cookies—it will not be eliminating the tracking cookie.
“Instead of deprecating third-party cookies, we would introduce a new experience in Chrome that lets people make an informed choice that applies across their web browsing, and they’d be able to adjust that choice at any time”
The announcement buried deep into the post came like a bolt out of the blue. A Privacy Sandbox website still maintains a timeline indicating that the third-party cookie phase-out should happen by Q2 2025. At the moment, Chrome has already restricted third-party cookies by default for 1% of Chrome stable version users, and 20% of Canary, Dev, and Beta users have been affected.
Informed choice
Instead of getting rid of third-party cookies, Google says it will offer “a new experience” in Chrome that would allow users to “make an informed choice that applies across their web browsing.” Chavez was scant on details as to how this informed choice concept would be implemented. Since we don’t have much — or rather, nothing at all, in terms of details, we can only speculate.
An “informed choice” sounds good if it’s implemented right. Ideally, users should be able to choose which data they want to share (for whatever reason), and which data they do not want anyone to be prying upon. The qualifier “informed” implies that users have all the necessary information to make these decisions, understanding exactly what data is being collected, how it will be used, who will have access to it, and the potential implications for their privacy. This transparency ensures that users are not unwittingly sacrificing their privacy and can make conscious decisions about their data.
If we look deeper at what a third-party cookie does, the choice, if indeed informed, should seemingly be a no-brainer. Third-party cookies essentially have no other use cases than to help advertisers, data brokers, and others to spy on users across the Web. Unlike first-party cookies, which store useful site-specific data (like login information), third-party cookies track users across different websites. This creates a detailed profile of a user’s browsing habits, interests, and online behavior.
Advertisers can then use this data to target users with ads that are eerily specific, often for products they’ve casually browsed but not necessarily purchased.
So the question is, with a clear understanding of what third-party cookies do, who would willingly allow them? Apple’s App Tracking Transparency (ATT) feature provides a real-world example. When users were given a direct choice to opt-in to app tracking, the vast majority opted out. Gaming apps, generally known for their targeted advertising, were more successful in persuading users to allow them to track them, but even in their case the average opt-in rate for tracking was a meager 37% in Q2 2023.
Going out on a limb here, but It’s likely that if Google follows in Apple’s footsteps, the third-party cookie adoption rates should not be high. While details of Chrome’s ‘informed choice’ are unclear, users rejecting third-party cookies might be directed to Google’s replacement system, the Protected Audiences API within the Privacy Sandbox initiative. The Privacy Sandbox offers a more private approach than third-party cookies, but only in isolation. When context is added, it hinders user tracking for smaller companies, but not necessarily for giants like Meta or Google itself, who benefit from vast portfolios of interconnected services.
Our doubts extend beyond the concept itself. Google’s history of using confusing interfaces, or ‘dark patterns,’ raises concerns about the genuineness of this ‘informed choice.’ For example, Chrome previously used a combination of settings to track user location. Even if users disabled Location History, Google could still track them through the default ‘Web & App Activity’ setting. This functionality of Web & App Activity for location harvesting wasn’t disclosed by Google until mid-2018 at the earliest.
Advertisers were not thrilled either
Not only privacy advocates cried foul over Google’s third-party cookie replacement, but also the advertisers themselves. Criteo, for example, reports that testing and publisher feedback suggest Google’s Privacy Sandbox, in its current form, falls short of the company’s stated goal of limiting publisher revenue loss to 5%. And that would be an understatement, since according to Criteo’s own analysis, if third-party cookies were deprecated today and the Privacy Sandbox released in its current state, publisher revenues would decrease “by an average of 60% for those that have fully integrated the Privacy Sandbox.”
It’s not much of a surprise either that the adoption rate for the new tech remained rather low, below 55%, according to Criteo. Criteo is far from being alone — many more advertising companies reported similar uninspiring results.
“We’re still seeing that 30% hit to revenue in Chrome cookieless world, and that’s a big amount of revenue for people to lose,” ad-tech company Raptive exec was recently cited as saying by Marketing Brew.
How will this impact privacy
Google’s decision to not sunset third-party cookies is a blow to privacy, make no mistake about it.
Almost all browsers are blocking them by default, while the others, like Microsoft’s Edge, are also on the path to phase them out (though, in the light of Google’s announcement, Microsoft may start having some second thoughts). That means then when all is said and done, Chrome will emerge as an outlier. At the same time it remains the most popular browser with an impressive 65% share of the market. What it means is that the majority of Internet users will be impacted by this decision, and in a bad way.
No matter how you twist the language, third-party cookies are an inherently non-private tracking mechanism. A tacit admission by Google that its replacement failed demonstrates that trying to have your cake and eat it too—protecting both privacy and advertisers’ interests—is hardly viable at present, at least in the way that Google had envisioned. Ultimately, while it aimed to cater to both sides, it failed to meet the expectations of either.
Currently, the onus is on the users to protect themselves from encroachments on their privacy, and ad blockers are one of the many tools available to help them with that. Relying on Google for privacy protection always seemed like a far-fetched idea — and the latest events have shown that if anything, Google is going in the opposite direction.
We’ve featured the best business VPN.
This article was produced as part of TechRadarPro’s Expert Insights channel where we feature the best and brightest minds in the technology industry today. The views expressed here are those of the author and are not necessarily those of TechRadarPro or Future plc. If you are interested in contributing find out more here: https://www.techradar.com/news/submit-your-story-to-techradar-pro
Google’s decision to delay the phase-out of third-party cookies impacts privacy and ad tech industry.
The Amazon Marketplace: Empowering Sellers and Shaping Consumer Behavior
The Amazon Marketplace has emerged as a powerful force in the global economy, redefining how businesses operate and how consumers shop. Since its launch in 2000, Amazon Marketplace has grown into one of the largest online marketplaces in the world, with millions of sellers and an even larger base of customers. This platform has not only democratized e-commerce, providing opportunities for businesses of all sizes, but it has also significantly influenced consumer behavior. This article explores how the Amazon Marketplace empowers sellers and shapes consumer behavior.
Empowering Sellers: Opportunities and Challenges
The Amazon Marketplace has opened up unprecedented opportunities for sellers, from individual entrepreneurs to large corporations. One of the most significant benefits for sellers is the access to Amazon’s vast customer base. With over 300 million active users globally, Amazon provides a ready-made audience for sellers, eliminating the need for extensive marketing efforts to drive traffic to their products.
Lower Barriers to Entry
One of the most profound ways Amazon empowers sellers is by lowering the barriers to entry into the e-commerce space. Traditionally, setting up an online store required significant investment in website development, payment processing systems, and logistics. Amazon Marketplace simplifies this process by providing a platform where sellers can list their products, handle transactions, and even manage shipping through Amazon’s Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) service.
FBA, in particular, has been a game-changer for many small and medium-sized businesses. It allows sellers to store their products in Amazon’s warehouses, where Amazon takes care of packing, shipping, and even customer service. This service not only reduces the logistical burden on sellers but also ensures that their products are eligible for Amazon Prime, which can significantly boost sales.
Global Reach
The global reach of Amazon Marketplace is another significant advantage for sellers. With Amazon’s presence in numerous countries, sellers can tap into international markets with relative ease. Amazon’s Global Selling program enables sellers to list their products in multiple countries, allowing them to expand their customer base far beyond their home market. This global reach is particularly beneficial for small businesses that may not have the resources to enter international markets independently.
Data and Analytics
Amazon provides sellers with valuable data and analytics tools that can help them optimize their listings and marketing strategies. Through the Seller Central dashboard, sellers have access to detailed reports on sales, customer behavior, and advertising performance. This data-driven approach allows sellers to make informed decisions about pricing, inventory management, and advertising, ultimately leading to better business outcomes.
Challenges for Sellers
However, selling on Amazon is not without its challenges. The competition on the platform is fierce, with millions of sellers vying for the attention of customers. To stand out, sellers must invest in optimizing their product listings, managing reviews, and running targeted advertising campaigns. Additionally, Amazon’s fee structure, which includes referral fees, FBA fees, and other charges, can eat into sellers’ profit margins, especially for those selling low-margin products.
Moreover, Amazon’s control over the marketplace means that sellers are subject to its policies and regulations. This can be a double-edged sword; while Amazon’s strict guidelines help maintain a level of quality and trust on the platform, they can also be restrictive for sellers. Policy changes, such as adjustments to fee structures or new regulations regarding product listings, can have a significant impact on sellers’ businesses.
Shaping Consumer Behavior: Convenience and Choice
The Amazon Marketplace has not only empowered sellers but also transformed consumer behavior in profound ways. The platform has become synonymous with convenience, choice, and competitive pricing, which are key drivers of consumer decisions.
Convenience and Speed
One of the most significant impacts of Amazon on consumer behavior is the expectation of convenience and speed. Amazon’s streamlined shopping experience, coupled with services like Amazon Prime, has set a new standard for online shopping. Consumers now expect fast, often same-day, delivery, easy returns, and a seamless shopping experience across devices. This has raised the bar for other e-commerce platforms and even brick-and-mortar stores, which have had to adapt to meet these heightened expectations.
The convenience offered by Amazon extends beyond just delivery speed. Features like one-click purchasing, personalized recommendations, and a user-friendly mobile app have made shopping on Amazon almost effortless. This ease of use has contributed to the platform becoming the go-to destination for many consumers, particularly for everyday purchases.
Broad Product Selection
Amazon’s vast selection of products is another factor that has shaped consumer behavior. The marketplace offers a seemingly endless array of products across virtually every category, from electronics to groceries. This extensive selection is possible because of the millions of third-party sellers who list their products on the platform, alongside Amazon’s own offerings.
This breadth of choice has shifted consumer expectations, leading to a preference for platforms that offer a wide variety of options. Consumers are now less willing to visit multiple websites or stores to find what they need, preferring the convenience of one-stop shopping. This trend has also put pressure on traditional retailers to expand their product offerings and improve their online shopping experiences.
Price Sensitivity and Competitive Pricing
Amazon’s pricing strategies have also influenced consumer behavior, making customers more price-sensitive. The platform’s dynamic pricing model, where prices can change frequently based on factors like demand and competition, encourages consumers to compare prices and seek out the best deals. Additionally, features like Amazon’s price tracking tools and the ability to view historical prices have made consumers more aware of price fluctuations and more likely to wait for discounts before making a purchase.
This increased price sensitivity has impacted the broader retail landscape, forcing competitors to adopt more aggressive pricing strategies to stay competitive. It has also led to the rise of price comparison tools and apps, further empowering consumers to find the best deals.
The Role of Reviews and Ratings
Amazon’s review system is another key factor influencing consumer behavior. Customer reviews and ratings have become a critical component of the decision-making process for many shoppers. Positive reviews can significantly boost a product’s visibility and sales, while negative reviews can deter potential buyers. This has led to a culture where consumers rely heavily on the experiences of others to guide their purchasing decisions.
The importance of reviews has also created a new challenge for sellers, who must actively manage their reputation on the platform. This has given rise to practices like review solicitation and even, unfortunately, fake reviews. However, Amazon has taken steps to combat these practices, implementing stricter policies and algorithms to detect and remove fraudulent reviews.
Conclusion
The Amazon Marketplace has had a profound impact on both sellers and consumers, reshaping the e-commerce landscape in the process. By empowering sellers with access to a global customer base, powerful data tools, and logistical support, Amazon has lowered the barriers to entry for businesses of all sizes. At the same time, the platform has transformed consumer behavior, setting new standards for convenience, choice, and pricing.
As Amazon continues to evolve, its influence on the global economy and consumer culture will likely only grow. For sellers, the challenge will be to navigate the complexities of the platform and find ways to stand out in an increasingly crowded marketplace. For consumers, the Amazon Marketplace will continue to be a driving force behind the expectations and behaviors that define the future of shopping.
